In the first three installments of our Special Quest series, we reviewed CBP’s new standards for U.S. and foreign Importers of Record (IORs) and the verification and recordkeeping responsibilities placed on customs brokers.
This installment focuses on the broader risks these requirements may create for customs brokers. Collecting additional personal, ownership and financial information may increase cyber and privacy exposure, while the foreign IOR provisions may require some brokers to act as IOR. At the same time, the schemes the IFR is designed to combat continue to create significant customs bond exposure.
CBP cited shell companies, concealed ownership, duty-evasion schemes and difficulty collecting customs debts among the concerns underlying the Executive Order and subsequent IFR. As CBP continues to evaluate customs bond requirements, brokers and sureties may also need to reconsider how they assess and monitor bond exposure.
The practical takeaway: IFR compliance and customs bond risk management should be considered together. Information collected during importer verification may also help identify warning signs before significant bond exposure accumulates.
Risk Management Considerations
No single control can eliminate these risks. However, information collected during IFR verification may also support broader risk management. The following are considerations brokers may wish to evaluate in light of their own procedures, risk tolerance, and bond portfolios.
Areas to consider include:
No single factor necessarily indicates fraud. It is often the combination of unusual factors that may signal the need for additional review.
4. Understand the exposure when the broker acts as IOR
The IFR creates another important consideration for CTPAT-validated brokers.
Under new 19 CFR § 141.21(b)(2), a foreign IOR that is not CTPAT validated must use a CTPAT-validated licensed customs broker to make entry or act as IOR. Importantly, when the foreign principal on the power of attorney is not the owner or purchaser of the merchandise, the designated CTPAT-validated broker must act as IOR.
Acting as IOR is more than an administrative designation. Acting as IOR makes the broker responsible for the import transaction, potentially increasing its customs, financial and regulatory exposure. Key considerations may include the following:
> Duty and tariff exposure can become significantActing as IOR may expose the broker to ordinary customs duties, AD/CVD, Section 301 and other tariffs, as well as liability arising from classification, valuation or country-of-origin issues. Additional bills may also arise after liquidation or reliquidation.
CBP reported approximately $1.01 billion in unpaid principal bills associated with non-CTPAT foreign IORs as of February 6, 2026. These figures illustrate the financial risk of assuming the IOR role for a foreign party whose assets may be difficult to reach.
> Penalty exposure: Why Getting U.S. IOR Status Right Matters.An incorrect IOR determination may also create regulatory exposure. 19 U.S.C. § 1592 authorizes civil penalties against any person who, through fraud, gross negligence or negligence, enters or introduces merchandise through a material false statement or omission.
Customs brokers may also face enforcement under 19 U.S.C. § 1641, including monetary penalties and possible suspension or revocation of a license or permit.
An important consideration: Because U.S. IOR status is declared on CBP Forms 3461 and 7501 or their electronic equivalents, an incorrect determination could be repeated across dozens or even hundreds of filings, potentially increasing penalty exposure. Consistent verification and documentation may therefore be particularly important.
Insurance coverage: Brokers should also consider whether their insurance policies will respond when they act as IOR, as many E&O policies contain exclusions or limitations that apply when the insured acts as importer or record rather than a customs broker.
> AD/CVD risk could be particularly dangerousAD/CVD exposure may be particularly significant because final liability can arise well after entry and may far exceed the broker’s fee or anticipated account revenue. A broker acting as IOR could therefore assume substantial customs liability for a foreign company whose assets may be difficult to reach.
> U.S.-based accountability and CTPAT exposureCBP has explained that collecting customs debts from foreign IORs can be difficult when their operations, assets and key personnel are outside the United States. A U.S.-based customs broker acting as IOR does not present the same collection obstacle.
Brokers may want to consider whether taking on the IOR role could increase CBP scrutiny and adversely affect broker compliance, CPTPAT standing and the broker’s own bond.
Bringing It All Together
The IFR is fundamentally about better identifying who is behind an import transaction. CBP has linked the IFR to concerns involving shell companies, obscured ownership, unpaid customs obligations and difficulty enforcing against foreign entities.
Those same issues can affect a broker’s bond portfolio. At the same time, complying with the IFR may create new exposures of its own, from handling more sensitive information to potentially assuming the IOR role.
The takeaway is not simply more vetting. It is an opportunity to consider importer verification, cybersecurity, credit review, bond underwriting, insurance and ongoing monitoring together.
No procedure can eliminate fraud or bond claims, but a coordinated approach may help brokers recognize unusual activity earlier, make more informed bond decisions and better understand the exposures they are assuming.
Avalon has created a resource page to track activity related to Executive Order 14411. It brings together official CBP updates, regulations, guidance and Avalon articles to help the trade community navigate the evolving requirements under Executive Order 14411, Strengthening Customs Enforcement.
This material is provided for general informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. The application of the IFR will depend on the specific facts and circumstances involved. Importers and customs brokers should consult qualified customs counsel regarding the rule’s application to their operations and review insurance coverage questions with their insurance advisor.